Truth and Reconciliation proposals on child welfare destined to fail

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Brian GiesbrechtFive calls to action in the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada report concern child welfare. They are all destined to fail.

The calls to action focus on increasing funding for Indigenous welfare, establishing national standards for the various agencies, keeping Indigenous children in culturally-relevant homes, and reducing the number of Indigenous children in the welfare system in comparison with non-Indigenous children.

A frightening number of Indigenous children aren’t being cared for properly in the homes of their biological parents and many of these children are being cared for in non-Indigenous homes.

In provinces like Manitoba, with a relatively large Indigenous population, the lion’s share of the children in the care of welfare agencies are, in fact, Indigenous. Although Indigenous people make up roughly 10 per cent of the population, more than 90 per cent of the approximately 11,000 children in care are Indigenous.

The simple reason: their parents’ drinking-and-drug-taking lifestyle.

The 1967 Calder Report examined nine residential schools in Saskatchewan, eight rural and one urban. The eight rural schools had upwards of 80 per cent of the students enrolled there by an Indian agent because of home conditions – usually drinking – that made it unsafe or dangerous for the children.

As the federal government had no mechanism to apprehend Indigenous children until well into the 1960s, Indian agents used residential schools to protect these children. Children from homes in which there’s considerable drinking tend not to do well in any school.

But the federal government and Indigenous advocates exacerbate the problem by providing parents with excuses for their irresponsible behaviour. The excuses include the usual: colonialism, residential schools, racism, etc.

Parents are absolved of their responsibility and there’s little incentive to change their behaviour.

This is one of the major causes neglected in the TRC Report. Fault is found with everyone except the people who could actually do something about it – the parents. The report pretends to treat Indigenous people as responsible adults but insists that Indigenous parents are helpless victims incapable of managing their lives. Everything is blamed on historical events they have no control over.

All five of the calls to action concerning child welfare reflect this troubling thinking. Government is called upon for yet more legislation and more money to deal with child welfare despite the fact that a truly staggering amount of money has been spent on Indigenous child welfare and things have only gotten worse.

The report continues to pretend that more legislation and more funding will solve this massive problem.

But governments are very limited in what they can do about what are essentially lifestyle choices. If people insist on living a drinking-and-drug-taking lifestyle, governments can legislate and they can cajole, but their powers are very limited.

When this is combined with the truly irresponsible policy of giving parents excuses in advance, it produces the alarming Indigenous child welfare results that we have in this country.

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission child welfare calls to action only perpetuate this way of thinking and guarantee that the problem will persist for years to come.

Brian Giesbrecht is a retired judge and a senior fellow at the Frontier Centre for Public Policy.

indigenous children trc child welfare

The views, opinions and positions expressed by columnists and contributors are the author’s alone. They do not inherently or expressly reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of our publication.

By Brian Giesbrecht

Brian Giesbrecht was a Provincial Court Judge in Manitoba from 1976 to 2007. During that time he served as Acting Chief Judge, and Associate Chief Judge. He is now retired and lives in western Manitoba.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.