Mentorship programs for troubled youth foster respect for others

Troubled girl
Reading Time: 4 minutes

By Suzanne Tough
and Nicole Letourneau
University of Calgary

The youth of any society constitute the promise of the future – and many of our youth are in trouble.

They’re growing up in a divided society. Ethnic, gender and political tensions are at seemingly combustible levels – not just south of the border but in Canada, too. Their employment is frequently temporary and unstable. And buying a home appears impossible for many, as inequity increases across society.

Youth most affected by such tensions and disparities may shrug their shoulders and wonder, ‘Why bother?’

Suzanne Tough
Suzanne Tough

But there’s one thing we can do to help at-risk Canadian youth forge a better future: provide positive mentorship.

Research shows that mentorship programs for youth improve school success and academic performance. For example, 45 per cent of at-risk youth with an adult mentor are enrolled in higher education compared to only 29 per cent of their unmentored peers. Mentorships also reduce drug and alcohol abuse, engagement in violence and with the law, and improve peer relationships, social skills and employment.

Unfortunately, too many young people in Canada don’t have an adult mentor.

Thirty per cent of youth report never having an adult mentor of any kind. Rates are higher for youth most at risk – including those from impoverished backgrounds and those with an incarcerated parent.

Mentorship programs for youth make good economic sense, too.

Nicole Letourneau

According to a 2014 report by the National Mentoring Partnership, every dollar invested in youth mentoring results in a $3 return on investment to society by, for example, reducing justice and health services costs, and improving employment (and thus government tax revenue).

Mentorship programs work for low-to-high-risk youth, although duration matters – mentorship is more successful when it extends beyond a year, so emotional bonds and trust develop.

And training programs for mentors, such as those led by Big Brothers Big Sisters and the Boys and Girls Clubs, ensure mentors learn the skills they need to succeed.

We must make certain that youth who need mentorship have adult men and women who are trained and ready to help. Youth often struggle to make sense of the many complex social issues, such as gender identity, immigration or refugee resettlement, racism and sexism.

Mentorship can foster shared understanding and respect, and help bridge gaps between contemporary values and traditional customs and habits. Mentors are the role models and teachers we need to help shape an inclusive and civic society.

So it’s a sad reality that almost 80 per cent of youth considered most at risk because of repeated school absence, school expulsion, course failure or grade repetition do not have the benefits of structured mentorship.

Youth mentorship should not be left to chance. What can be done?

  • Normalize, popularize and celebrate mentorship. Communities, schools, not-for-profit organizations and the private sector can embed mentorship programs in strategic planning, evaluation and investment planning. The private sector can recognize employee contributions to mentorship the same way participation in other corporate philanthropy is celebrated.
  • At-risk youth can be identified by teachers, in the juvenile justice system and in child welfare/foster-care systems. Matching them to the best mentors could dramatically improve the life chances for these youth. A mentorship match should be standard of care for them.
  • As early as elementary school age, children at risk of academic failure should be identified and provided with quality mentorship. These include those with poor attendance and/or who struggle with math and reading.

This latter point was perfectly articulated in one of our studies by an impoverished young pregnant woman who suffered from a serious addiction. “You would have had to get me in Grade 3 to prevent me from ending up where I am now,” she said. Her words have haunted us for more than a decade. She spent her childhood and youth doing the best she could to survive in her environment – and society failed her.

At a time when ‘fear of the other’ is broadcast on a daily basis, the potential for an inclusive and compassionate society is threatened. Mentorship and engagement with those around us can help build a diverse and peaceful society we can all be proud of.

Suzanne Tough is a professor in the Cumming School of Medicine and Nicole Letourneau is a professor in the Faculties of Nursing and Medicine at the University of Calgary.

Suzanne and Nicole are Troy Media Thought Leaders. Why aren’t you?

© Troy Media

mentorship programs troubled youth

The views, opinions and positions expressed by columnists and contributors are the author’s alone. They do not inherently or expressly reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of our publication.

By Suzanne Tough

Dr. Tough is a Professor with the Departments of Paediatrics and Community Health Sciences in the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Calgary, and holds adjunct appointments at with the University of Alberta and the University of Manitoba. She is also the Scientific Director of the Alberta Centre for Child, Family and Community Research, an organization whose vision is to improve child, family and community well-being through applied research. Dr. Tough’s research program seeks to improve the health and well-being of women during pregnancy to achieve optimal maternal, birth and early childhood outcomes. Specifically, Dr. Tough has research interests in the area of maternal and child health, preconception and prenatal care, low birth weight and preterm birth, delayed childbearing, and fetal alcohol spectrum disorders. The underlying aim of Dr. Tough’s research program is to create evidence that informs the development of community and clinical programs and influences policy to optimize birth and childhood outcomes. She is a co-leader of an interdisciplinary research team (Preterm Birth and Healthy Outcomes) funded by the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.